Subtle Sexuality: The Replacement aired on October 29, 2009 and was written by Nate Federman and Jonathan Hughes, who also wrote The Office: Blackmail and The Office: The Outburst. It was directed by Mindy Kaling who made her directorial debut with these webisodes. It was the second episode of the internet spin-off of The Office.
Erin explains that Kelly and Ryan are fighting. Erin tries to convince Kelly that she can do it, and then Kevin asks if he can be Ryan's replacement, however, Kelly offers him to hold the camera. Andy, taking interest, sings, and Erin and Kelly go to see him. Andy explains that he auditioned, and was accepted. Kelly teaches Andy and Erin how to dance. Ryan, angirly, comes in asking how Kelly can make out with Andy. Kelly tells Ryan that she'll be thinking about him while kissing Andy, and they make-out themselves.
- Mindy Kaling as Kelly Kapoor
- B.J. Novak as Ryan Howard
- Ellie Kemper as Erin Hannon
- Ed Helms as Andy Bernard
|Blackmail||Subtle Sexuality - Webisodes||Season 6|
|#01||Creative Differences||#02||The Replacement||#03||The Music Video|